I’ve put my lawyer hat on for this post so expect it to be a little bit boffin-esque in places.
The ultimate fate of the man convicted of the Lockerbie bombing, Abdelbaset Ali Mohmed Al Megrahi, has become a political hot-potato in the past few weeks. And while opposition politicians, including Labour’s Justice Spokesman Richard Baker, have attempted to make political hay out of the issue little consideration has been given to the difficult balancing act being performed by the Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill. The issues Mr. MacAskill has to consider include:
- The fact of Mr. Megrahi’s severe illness;
- The considerable distance between him and his family;
- The fact that any other criminal convicted of any other crime would likely be serving his sentence in his home country;
- The scale of the crime for which he has been convicted;
- The overwhelming body of evidence that suggests an injustice has been done.
Mr. MacAskill I know to have had a long career as a pursuer reparation solicitor (ambulance chaser) and therefore has the requisite legal mind to exercise the quasi-judicial powers of Justice Secretary. Those of us in opposition parties would do well to remember that this is not a political matter, and that Mr. MacAskill nor the SNP Government have nothing to gain politically from releasing Mr. Megahi.
Scottish Labour has attempted to make an issue out of the unprecedented visit paid by the Justice Secretary to Greenock Prison, but the fact is that this whole scenario is without precedent. I don’t blame the Justice Secretary for wanting to see with his own eyes the condition of Mr. Megrahi, given the importance of the decision he has before him.
Meanwhile, Tavish Scott has tried to score points by asking for parliament to be recalled. Again this achieves nothing, as the release of prisoners is a function for the Executive to consider, and not the legislature. Mr. MacAskill should be left to consider the matter free from the political pressure that would inevitably be applied by parliament.

Secretary Clinton: wrong for once
And finally, U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton would do well to remember that this is absolutely none of her business, and her unusual intervention is an unwelcome intrusion into domestic matters. Megrahi is a Libyan man, convicted of committing a crime in Scotland by a Scottish court and held in a Scottish prison. The fact that American citizens were amongst the victims of the Lockerbie Bombing is immaterial.
I have every confidence that Mr. Megrahi will be freed soon – quite possibly by the end of the week. While this will not be the satisfactory conclusion that so many seek, it would go a long way to righting what most people accept is one of the greatest miscarriages of Scots justice.
August 19th, 2009 | |
Posted in Holyrood |